Back to Commentary
    Housing & PolicyWho Actually Pays?

    Australia Wants 1.2 Million New Homes. But Who Can Afford to Build Them?

    What happens when the cost of building a new home no longer makes financial sense compared with buying an existing one?

    Mark Kilroy
    RICS Chartered Quantity Surveyor (MRICS) · AIQS Certified Quantity Surveyor (MAIQS CQS) · Registered Tax Agent
    Published · Updated
    Australian display village at dusk with completed homes and a timber-framed house under construction, titled Queensland New Home Sales Down 36.8%. What does it mean for housing supply in 2027?

    Queensland's new home sales have fallen 36.8% over the past three months compared with the previous three months.

    Nationally, sales fell 19.3% in October alone.

    Those are concerning figures. But I think there is a bigger problem here that deserves more attention.

    What happens when the cost of building a new home no longer makes financial sense compared with buying an existing one?

    As a quantity surveyor, I spend a great deal of time looking at construction costs, project feasibility and what it actually costs to deliver a building.

    And this is where I see a growing contradiction in Australia's housing policy.

    We have a national target of 1.2 million new homes over five years. We have governments talking about improving housing affordability, increasing supply and making development easier.

    Yet the financial conditions facing the people expected to deliver those homes are becoming increasingly difficult.

    Consider what happens when established property prices start falling.

    A buyer looks at an existing home and compares it with buying land and building something similar.

    The new home has to account for the land, construction, site works, approvals, financing, holding costs and the risks associated with building.

    Meanwhile, the established home is already there, ready to occupy.

    If the established property becomes cheaper while the cost of constructing a replacement remains elevated, the decision becomes increasingly difficult.

    That is not simply a buyer confidence problem. It is a feasibility problem.

    And you cannot fix that by announcing another housing target.

    The numbers should concern Queensland

    The latest HIA figures show Queensland has experienced the sharpest decline in new home sales of the five major states surveyed.

    And remember, this slowdown was already happening before the Reserve Bank increased interest rates again on 3 November.

    What concerns me is the delay between a contract being signed and a home actually being delivered.

    Builders may still have substantial work underway today. But if new contracts are not replacing completed projects, that workload eventually disappears.

    The consequences will not necessarily be obvious until well into 2027.

    By then, businesses may have reduced their workforce, subcontractors may have moved elsewhere and future construction capacity may already have been lost.

    There is another question nobody seems to be answering

    How do we expect construction costs to become more affordable when we are simultaneously increasing the financial pressures on the industry?

    We have higher borrowing costs, significant infrastructure commitments, ongoing construction cost pressures and additional costs associated with regulation and some imported building materials.

    Each issue can be discussed separately.

    But a builder or developer cannot look at them separately.

    They all end up in the same feasibility calculation.

    And ultimately, someone has to pay.

    For Queensland, this is particularly relevant with Brisbane 2032 approaching and billions of dollars of infrastructure work planned.

    Those projects are important. But they will also require construction labour, subcontractors and resources that the residential sector needs.

    We should be asking whether enough consideration is being given to the combined impact on the cost of delivering housing.

    We need more than housing announcements

    I am not suggesting interest rates should be kept low regardless of inflation. Inflation is a serious problem for households and businesses.

    But higher rates do not reduce the cost of concrete, steel, labour or getting a building approved.

    They do, however, change the financial viability of building.

    And when the numbers no longer work, projects do not proceed.

    Australia has already experienced enough construction cycles to understand the consequences of losing building capacity and then trying to rebuild it when demand returns.

    We should be measuring the success of housing policy by the number of homes that can actually be delivered at a price people can afford.

    Not simply by the number of homes governments announce they intend to build.

    Because if a new home costs more to deliver than buyers can justify paying, who is going to build the 1.2 million homes Australia is counting on?

    “Property is bought once. It has to be held every day.”
    Mark Kilroy

    Explore further

    Work with Mark

    Assess how your asset is performing through the holding phase.

    Apply for a HOLD Review

    Share this article

    Republishing

    You're welcome to republish this article in full or in part, provided it includes clear attribution to Mark Kilroy and a link back to the original at markkilroy.com.au.

    For media enquiries, syndication requests, or to discuss republishing in print or digital publications, please get in touch.

    The Kilroy Brief

    One practical briefing on the policy, tax, cost and cash-flow forces shaping Australian property ownership. For owners, investors and advisers who want the mechanics behind the headlines. Sent when there is something worth saying, not to fill a schedule.

    Mark Kilroy: RICS Chartered Quantity Surveyor (MRICS) · AIQS Certified Quantity Surveyor (MAIQS CQS) · Registered Tax Agent. He has 25+ years of experience in construction cost analysis and tax depreciation across Australia, the UK and the US. He is the founder of Koste Chartered Quantity Surveyors and a Queensland Committee Member of the Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors.

    More commentary at markkilroy.com.au/commentary.